Line of Flight: A Q & A with Novelist Evelyn Herwitz

Evelyn Herwitz and I have been writing accountability partners for more than a decade, cheering each other on and commiserating as needed via (almost) daily emails, occasional phone calls when an email doesn’t suffice, and rare real life meet-ups when travel plans allow. Over the years I have watched her debut historical novel, Line of Flight, which is set in 1915 during the Great War, evolve into its current beautifully written and deeply researched form.

Line of Flight is coming out November 17 (today!). I’m delighted to have Evelyn here on the Margins to talk about the book and and how she wrote it.

What inspired you to write Line of Flight?

Writers start from different points, often beginning with a character, but in my case, I began with a setting, World War I. I never learned much about the Great War in high school, because it was eclipsed by lessons about World War II, which was relatively recent history. But two serendipitous visits to museums while I was on business trips piqued my curiosity. In 2010, I saw an evocative exhibit of Otto Dix’s WWI etchings, Der Krieg, that were part of a retrospective at the Neue Galerie in NYC. The images punched me in the gut. Then in 2014 I visited the National World War I Museum and Memorial in Kansas City, Missouri. I was completely overwhelmed by this war that I had never paid any attention to, which shaped so much of our world today. There was a display case with uniforms worn by women ambulance drivers, about whom I also knew nothing. That was the spark.

Line of Flight is such an evocative title. Could you tell us the story behind it?

In an early draft of the novel, there was a scene where a pigeon waddled along a sidewalk, leading Camilla, one of the lead characters, to a sign for a fortune teller. The fortune teller never made it into the final version, but the pigeon stayed. I was working on early drafts while taking a class at Grub Street in Boston, and I would watch the pigeons at the Back Bay station while waiting for my train back to Worcester. I was fascinated by them, so easily overlooked. So I began to read more about them and learned how carrier pigeons can always find their way home, possibly by sensing magnetic fields. That phenomenon is called line of flight. Given that the story is about a mother and daughter trying to find themselves and each other, it was the perfect metaphor.

How did you walk the line between historical fact and fiction in Line of Flight?

I tried very hard to use historical fact as a framework for the story. I checked a lot of details and dates and read extensively about the war and its impact. But I also played with those details. For instance, when the Lusitania sinks, I place Simone on one of the only lifeboats that remained intact. Of course, she wasn’t there, but she could have been.

What types of sources do you rely on to create rich fictional characters who are historically accurate?

You can find so much information on the internet, of course, though you have to vet it. I read many books about everything from the training of carrier pigeons to the lives of women ambulance drivers. I also used primary source material from The New York Public Library, which holds a collection of correspondence about the American Fund for French Wounded, as well as demographic details about the New Orleans Jewish community that emigrated from Alsace and Lorraine in France after the Franco-Prussian War that I discovered at The Historic New Orleans Collection. In addition, I found diaries by nurses and doctors who served at the American Ambulance Hospital in Paris. The letters and diaries especially informed my writing, because they captured the way that people told stories and expressed themselves—in much greater detail than we do today in glib text messages.

Did you base your characters on real-life historical women?

Simone and Camilla are women of my own imagination. The one historical woman in the story is Dr. Mary Crawford, who was a surgeon at the American Ambulance Hospital in 1915. I read her letters that were published in the Cornell Women’s Review—that you helped me to locate!—about her experiences, and then gave her a role as Camilla’s mentor at the hospital.

What was the most surprising thing you’ve found doing historical research for your work?

How much I just love digging! It can be both a blessing and a curse, because I can tunnel down rabbit holes for hours trying to track down some detail and then get totally distracted from the work of writing. Or,  I admit, it can be a great excuse to not tackle the blank page.

How did your career as a journalist shape your approach to writing Line of Flight?

It certainly taught me how to research and also how to get to the point of “triangulation,” when you have dug up so many details that start to overlap enough that you know you have the story right.

Historical research for a book, whether fiction or non-fiction, inevitably turns up more than ever makes it to the page. (That’s what blogs are for!) Is there something you uncovered in your research that you were sad to leave out?

I could have written a lot more about pigeons! I really came to appreciate them as gentle, faithful creatures with this incredible homing ability. They come in so many shapes and colors. I never got to a pigeon fancier’s convention, but I would have liked to. I had a lot of fun creating Ozma, who definitely has a mind of her own as she flies in and out of the story.

Photo credit: Joshua Meyer

Evelyn Herwitz has been telling stories since childhood, when she entertained her sister with songs about a dancing ant. For her own two daughters, now grown, resilient women, she concocted tales of talking moths and chipmunks; from them, she learned hard parenting lessons that inspired Line of Flight. Evelyn taught feature writing at Clark University in her hometown of Worcester, Mass., and has told stories professionally as a public radio and award-winning print journalist, a marketing and communications specialist, and an author. Her environmental history of Worcester, Trees at Risk (Chandler House Press, 2001), was cited as “a major historical work with a strong environmental message.” Now devoted to writing fiction, she is a graduate of Grub Street’s Novel Generator in Boston. Her stories have been published in Chautauqua, The Writing Disorder, and Embark Literary Journal. Line of Flight is her first novel.

To learn more about Evelyn and Line of Flight:

Check out her website: https://evelynherwitz.com/

Read her blog, History Making: https://evelynherwitz.substack.com/

 

 

 

Word with a Past: Cartoon

 

I had long been aware of two meanings of the word cartoon: one from the world of fine art and the other from popular culture. During a recent stroll through the history of political cartooning in the United States, I learned that the two meanings were linked at a very specific moment in time.

Originally the word cartoon, coming from the Italian cartone meaning a large sheet of heavy paper, referred to a full-scale preparatory drawing on paper done by an artist in preparation for a work of art, such as a fresco, painting, or tapestry. Art historians and museum curators still use the word with this way in some contexts. A term of art, as it were.[1]

What we think of as cartoons were called caricatures. That changed in July, 1843, when illustrator and satirical artist John Leech (1817-1864)[2] gave the word “cartoon” a new twist in the weekly British humor magazine Punch

In the depths of the “Hungry 40s,” the British government held a competition for a commission for murals to decorate the houses of Parliament, which had been damaged by fire. The government displayed the cartoons (in the original sense) that had been entered in the contest in a public exhibition with an entry fee of one shilling. Feeling that the money could be put to better use, Punch published a drawing by Leech of a ragged crowd of the poor, many of them children, gazing at a lavish display of paintings in a gallery reminiscent of the annual exhibit at the Royal Academy The drawing was titled “Cartoon No. 1–Substance and Shadow.” The accompanying editorial summed up the scene: “The poor ask for bread and the philanthropy of the State accords an exhibition.”

After Punch’s application of the term “cartoon” to this satirical drawing , the word began to be applied first to the type of satirical pictures the magazine was famous for and later to drawings that we would recognize as cartoons today [3]. In the twentieth century, the word expanded to include animation.

To quote Porky Pig, “th.., th.. that’s all folks!”

[1] Sorry. Sometimes I can’t resist

[2] Leed created some 30000 illustrations for Punch over the course of 20 years.  (I’ll let you do the math.)  Many of them addressed social problems, particularly those dealing with Britain’s poor. He also illustrated novels, including the first edition of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol (1844).

[3] I hate to  resort to Supreme Court Justice Stewart Potter’s definition of pornography –“I know it when I see it”–but writing a definition of cartoons as we know them proved to be surprisingly difficult.  The dictionaries I usually consult didn’t do much better.

A Rabbit Hole Designed with History Nerds in Mind

John Tenniel’s White Rabbit from the original illustrations for Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, from which the concept of going down the rabbit hole derives. In case you were wondering.

A few days ago, I found an interesting history sight in an unexpected place: Electric Speed, a newsletter from a writing expert named Jane Friedman[1]. In addition to sharing resources for writers and musing about all things writing, she often shares other resources that she has enjoyed. In this issue in addition to a source for a rum cake that she swears by, she offered a link to a dangerous site called Any Human Ever.

The idea is that history is a collection of stories, something I heartily agree with. Basically, you click through a series of buttons which create a random human from a random time and place. (You make no choices, other than to keep going.) It then gives you a snapshot of the statistical odds they faced—with links to sources for the information. And finally, it tells their story, complete with sources for the details, and a few images to bring their world to life.

My first draw was a girl named Li, born in 523 CE in the Yangzte River basin near Changsha, China, who died at the age of 11 from malnutrition. The site filled in what her family ate, what toys she payed with, what religion her family practiced, and what language they spoke. Fascinating.

I could spend a lot of time playing with this if I’m not careful!

[1] She also produces a paid newsletter called The Bottom Line, in which she analyzes trends n the writing business. I subscribed briefly, but it made me anxious.