In Which a Reader Asks a Question, and I Go Searching for the Answer

One of the delights of writing this blog is correspondence with like-minded people who have questions or thoughts about my posts. It is always a treat.

In response to my last post, a reader with whom I often correspond asked a question I had never even considered: If Jewish American or Jewish British or Jewish French soldiers were captured by the Germans, were they sent to a concentration camp for extermination or to a regular POW camp? *

I did a quick check through my usual sources. Nothing. I asked My Own True Love if he had knew.** He didn’t—though he agreed that it was a great question. Finally, I turned to a source that hasn’t failed me yet: the reference librarians at the Pritzker Military Library.*** They had an answer for me in an hour and a half.

Sadly, the answer is that the Nazis did single out Jewish soldiers. The United States Army made it easy to identify Jewish soldiers by marking a solder’s religious preference on his dog tag: C for Catholic, H for Hebrew,**** P for Protestant. According to an oral history in the Pritzker collection, the Nazis didn’t bother checking dog tags. They simply asked Jewish soldiers to identify themselves.

Soldiers identified as Jewish, or even potentially Jewish, were separated from other America prisoners and sent to the slave labor camp at Berga, which had the highest death rate of any of the POW camps, or to the extermination camps.

More information is available in a book titled Forgotten Victims: The Abandonment of Americans in Hitler’s Camps.  I haven’t read it, but it has good reviews.


Thanks to Dr. Gene for a great question. And to Pritzker librarian Leah Cohen for the sobering answer.


*You people are smart!

**He knows a lot more about World War II than I do. Or at least different things.

***If you are interested in military history, you should be aware of the Pritzker. They have interesting exhibits (the current exhibits are on women’s service organizations in WWII and WWI posters-both subjects dear to my heart), a solid research collection, an enormous collection of war posters, and kick-ass reference librarians. They collect veteran’s stories in an oral history program, Stories of Service. They also host excellent speakers. Even before the current troubles, they streamed many of their programs live.  I have spent many a happy evening in front of my computer with my knitting and a notebook, listening to experts talk about their passions.

****Obviously problematic


  1. Lissa Johnston on September 23, 2020 at 4:51 pm

    I’m currently on a slave labor research tangent, so thx for the tip on Berga.

    • Pamela on September 25, 2020 at 2:10 pm

      Always glad to help. 🙂

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.